When Malu Halasa and Rana Salam visited the souqs and
shops of Damascus and Aleppo during a visit a couple of
years ago, they were surprised by the apparent
contradiction between the unusually audacious and
playful lingerie on display there and the relatively
conservative society, in which so many women are veiled.
Halasa and Salam soon decided to co-author a book, "The
Secret Life of Syrian Lingerie: Intimacy and Design,"
which was published recently by Chronicle Books of San
Francisco with support from the Prince Claus Fund
Library of the Netherlands.
Sensual Syrian playfulness
The colorful pages of the book are full of photographs
of lingerie decorated with everything from birds,
butterflies and feathers to fake scorpions, flowers and
fur. Sequins, pearls, embroidery and tassels liberally
adorn bra and panty sets. Some lingerie sets emit music,
others vibrate or incorporate lights. Lingerie may be
edible; in other cases it is hidden inside chocolates or
eggs. There are crocheted one-piece body suits, and
costumes influenced by belly-dancing gear. The lingerie
often has a playfulness about it, with comic touches
such as fake fur thongs which double as mobile phone
holders.
In addition to photographs of the lingerie on display,
the book has photographs of lingerie modeled by
pale-skinned women, mostly East European. These pictures
are from catalogues readily available in lingerie
outlets, despite the taboo on the showing of explicit
images of women in public.
One of those Halasa interviewed for the book is Syrian
writer and political activist Ammar Abdulhamid (who
lives as a dissident in the USA). He describes Syria as
a traditional culture facing a postmodern culture. "If
you take a cross section of Syrian culture, you are
going to see a spectrum of different cultural values
that cross a thousand years, but they all exist right
now in one single moment."
Bringing Mid-Eastern popular culture to the West
Halasa and Salam have a long record of bringing Middle
Eastern popular culture to the West. Halasa, who is of
mixed Jordanian and Filipino parentage, has contributed
to numerous publications and books in Britain and the
US. She is a founding editor of the cultural magazine
Tank, and a former managing editor of the Prince Claus
Fund Library. Among the books she has co-authored are
"Creating Spaces of Freedom: Culture in Defiance",
"Transit Beirut" and "Transit Tehran".
Rana Salam, whose roots are in Lebanon, is a graduate of
Central St Martin's College of Art and Design in London
and of the Royal College of Art. Her design studio is
inspired by Middle Eastern popular art and street
culture, and her clients include institutions such as
the Victoria & Albert Museum and major retailers such as
Liberty, Harvey Nichols and Paul Smith.
Halasa's essay 'Competing Thongs: The Lingerie Culture
of Syria', takes the reader on a tour of the lingerie
manufacturers and shops of Damascus and Aleppo. Lingerie
has become an essential part of the wedding trousseau:
"If a groom doesn't buy the lingerie for his wife-to-be,
the bride herself or her mother does, sometimes
collecting up to thirty outfits for her wedding night."
The essay is accompanied by Lebanese photographer Reine
Mahfouz's photographs of lingerie factories, window
displays and shops where veiled women buy lingerie from
male assistants.
"Syrian society tackles sexuality head-on"
Halasa asks Abdulhamid about Syria's reputation within
the region for earthiness and raunchiness. He replies:
"Syrian society tackles sexuality head-on and looks at
it in a very direct manner, which some people might find
strange because it is supposedly a conservative
society." There is overt discussion of sexuality even in
mixed gatherings of men and women. "Sometimes it doesn't
matter whether the people are religious or not. Sexual
jokes are common currency in Syrian society."
There is a double edge to his comments on
the racy type of Syrian lingerie. On the one hand,
"you're turning women into sex toys. They're not
supposed to be sexually stimulating to other people, but
at home, to the husband, they're supposed to provoke his
sexuality and dress in the manner that will attract him
and do whatever he says." But at the same time, "it
gives women a lot of control. Women can use sexuality to
manipulate men."
Provoking embarrassment
The book furthermore includes a journal written by the Aleppo-born Canadian filmmaker Nora Kevorkian when she went to Damascus in 2001 to make the film "Veils Uncovered" about women living near Souq al-Hamadiyeh. The prizewinning film angered some individuals and Syrian political groups who alleged that it stereotyped Muslim women.
"The Secret Life of Syrian Lingerie" may itself attract such criticisms. Interviews with women are interspersed with photographs of lingerie by Lebanese photographer Gilbert Hage, but many women turned down the request to be interviewed, or became angry when they saw examples of the lingerie.
A woman in her sixties who declined to be interviewed declared: "Damascenes are proud of their city and culture. No one will talk to you." Another said: "Lingerie is such an embarrassing issue for Syrian women to talk about, and that's probably why it's called 'the secret life'."
Naïve, sweet and innocent
One interviewee pointed out that the type of lingerie highlighted in the book is only a small part of Syria's overall lingerie output, and is linked only to a small category of people. "There are subcultures in Syria, and subcultures everywhere else in the world that would be interested in this kind of lingerie, starting from Le Lido or Moulin Rouge." But another interviewee thought the lingerie is "almost done in a naive sweet innocent way. It's not sick or perverted."
The interviewees often associated the "exotic" lingerie with a certain class or religion. One said: "The underwear makes me laugh so much. It is not sexy at all!" She considers it mirrors "the very old fashioned ideas about sexuality in the less educated classes of Syria."
Another said that for Christians, the underwear is "nothing but embarrassing, old-fashioned fun; for Muslims it is something very normal – they not only accept it but also enjoy it. The more religious an area is, the more risqué the underwear becomes. I think that Muslim women have less freedom on the outside so to compensate they have more freedom on the inside."
"The Secret of Life of Syrian Lingerie: Intimacy and Design" is one of the most unusual, even bizarre, books you are likely to see on the Arab world. It is surely the first book to probe an Arab culture via the medium of its female undergarments, and looks certain to arouse debate and controversy.
The Secret Life of Syrian Lingerie: Intimacy and Design, Malu Halasa and Rana Salam (ed.), Chronicle Books San Francisco, 2008, 176 pages.
